Real Madrid squad under fire: 'Not at a worthy level' as critics sharpen knives
Analysis of the growing criticism aimed at Real Madrid's squad balance and hierarchy following recent struggles, with players and board both facing tough questions.
Trouble at the Bernabéu as voices grow louder questioning not just the manager but the entire sporting structure at Real Madrid, with critics suggesting the current squad simply isn’t cutting the mustard.
Squad imbalance taking center stage
The knives are well and truly out for Real Madrid’s squad planning. What started as grumbles about tactical approaches has evolved into a full-blown inquest about whether the players assembled at the club are actually up to scratch.
The criticism focuses particularly on the midfield, where many believe the squad lost its conductor after Kroos departed. Despite the manager reportedly requesting a specific type of organizing midfielder to replace him, the club opted to strengthen in other areas instead.
This disconnect between dugout wishes and boardroom decisions has become a recurring theme in Madrid circles, with preparation and physical conditioning seemingly prioritized over tactical coherence.
Dressing room power dynamics
Perhaps more concerning for Madrid supporters is the apparent power imbalance within the squad itself. The sight of star players seemingly making on-pitch decisions that override managerial instructions has raised serious eyebrows.
When players - particularly new signings like Mbappé - appear to have more authority than the gaffer, you’re on a hiding to nothing. It creates an environment where implementing a consistent tactical approach becomes nearly impossible.
Board under the microscope
Florentino Pérez isn’t escaping criticism either. The president’s transfer policy is increasingly viewed as overly conservative, a strategy that works splendidly when the trophies are rolling in but looks decidedly dodgy when results take a turn.
The possible promotion of Álvaro Arbeloa has been floated as a potential solution, with some sections of supporters seeing him as embodying the club’s traditional values. However, others are warning that the same fans backing him now could quickly turn if results don’t improve.
The bigger picture
The situation boils down to fundamental questions about Madrid’s sporting model:
- Who truly calls the shots at the Bernabéu?
- Is there a coherent sporting vision beyond star signings?
- Has the squad balance been neglected in favor of marquee additions?
For a club of Real Madrid’s stature, these aren’t just passing concerns but existential questions about their identity and future direction. Right now, the squad depth and quality in certain positions is leaving many to wonder if they’ve taken their eye off the ball.